Is Mcdohl a good owner of the soul eater?

deadfoxx

Personally i don't think so. For one the rune is supposed to be kept secret and barely used. Hes a national hero for the toran republic and so hes a perosn in the public eye with alot of the members of the govt knowing that he has the forbidden rune. And he used his powers a lot during the war. Also I doubt with his ability to draw people to him he would want to have to watch them all grow old while hes basically immortal.

How do you feel about this? and if you agree with me whose a better user?

Sesshomaru · Posted: Sat Jul 24, 2004 12:19 pm Post subject:

Mcdohl only used souleater when it was necesseary.Like when Windy tried to take it on numerous occasions,therefore hes a good owner of the souleater.
_________________
Theres only one truth-Conan Edigawa

Maken · Posted: Sat Jul 24, 2004 2:26 pm Post subject:

yeah it's horrible , but I agree Sesshomaru , he uses the Souleater when it necessary or when he goes to war , and he uses it against his enemy I doubt he would harm the innocent people .
_________________
"I'm the wizard maken proud miner of the golden land of Tinto"

Wiseman · Posted: Sat Jul 24, 2004 2:47 pm Post subject:

The person he was supposed to keep it secret from was Windy, and obviously she knew he had it whether he used it or not so it really didn't matter. After the war when he wandered with Gremio I would imagine he used it sparingly though, if at all.
_________________

Guardian of the Great Forest

Battle wounds and scars is how I show my pain
My palms covered in the blood of those I've slain
Yet I still keep comin back all the same...

deadfoxx · Posted: Sat Jul 24, 2004 3:12 pm Post subject:

It wasn't just Windy that they were keeping it a secret from it was more like hiding it and everyone who has knowledge about who has it a secret from those who would use the information and try to use the wielder for the wrong purpose. With all of his friends that he has what is stopping someone from taking a friend of his hostage if he doesnt comply with him.
Not only that but i doubt as i said earlier that he would want to be immortal.
_________________
Strength and speed are nothing. Skill and technique that is how you win a battle.

Gwendal · Posted: Sat Jul 24, 2004 5:23 pm Post subject:

Well, who made it a "forbidden Rune"? Tir doesn`t speak, so it`s hard to say much about his personality. And you seem to imply that every True Rune should be kept secret, and that it must suck for the bearer to watch their friends grow old and die. The ideal True Rune bearer must be a hermit, then. :)

As for the Soul Eater in particular...since it`s curse is so horrible, even for a True Rune, no one should wear it...the best thing to do would probably be sealing it off like the Flame Champion and Han/Genkaku did.
_________________

Darkmagus · Posted: Sat Jul 24, 2004 5:54 pm Post subject:

I agree. It is the cursed rune. The bearer carries the curse around with him where ever he goes. It's curse steals the lives of the bearers friends, but also grows stronger as it steals. Notice as Odessa, Gremio, Teo, and Ted die that new abilities become avaliable from the Soul Eater. Soul Eater is just about the worse True Rune to have. It may be next to the Rune of Punishment for being the worse true runes.
_________________

Njord · Posted: Sun Jul 25, 2004 2:53 am Post subject:

Well I would not agree with you, I say that the Souleater is better being with Tir since he is the only one to understand the pain of bearing this rune and the full responsibility of keeping it safe from the hands of evil.
_________________

Gwendal · Posted: Sun Jul 25, 2004 11:41 am Post subject:

As I said earlier, wouldn`t it be better to seal it away using one of those Sindar techniques then? He could just keep it deep inside a vault and maybe check on it from time to time...
_________________

Njord · Posted: Sun Jul 25, 2004 11:59 am Post subject:

zeal · Posted: Sun Jul 25, 2004 12:36 pm Post subject:

I think sealing is a good idea but very hard cause not many people know how to seal runes. but since he has sometime soooooo yes.

tir might die like 5 mins after sealing the rune cause he has had the rune of a long time, but then again didn't jimba live for sometime without the Water Rune?
_________________
First Bearer of the Scarlet Moon: zeal

Check out:
Car Accidents
I'm A Plus Size Model
Superslut
Rene Magritte/Surrealism

Cirape · Posted: Sun Jul 25, 2004 4:45 pm Post subject:

But wasn't the sealing of the True Fire Rune what caused the big explosion at the end of the first Fire Bringer war?

Of course, this begs the question of what Jimba/Wyatt did differently than the Fire Hero.
In the manga, however, Jimba still has the rune on his hand, its just dorment. Perhaps he just sealed (most of?) its powers where as the Fire Hero tried to get rid of it completly?
_________________
Where am I going--I don't quite know. What does it matter where people go?
Off to the woods where the blue bells grow--Anywhere! Anywhere! I don't know.
--???

zeal · Posted: Sun Jul 25, 2004 4:53 pm Post subject:

the huge explosion was an out of control use of the rune not sealing it. Tir used the rune's powers to get windy away. Luc used the wind rune in suikoden 2.

i think if i remember correctly now that Jimba/ Wyatt didn't seal the rune until Yum or whatever killed herself and that sealed the rune.

and the pervious flame champion didn't die right after he sealed the rune he lived for a couple years in the hideout.
_________________
First Bearer of the Scarlet Moon: zeal

Check out:
Car Accidents
I'm A Plus Size Model
Superslut
Rene Magritte/Surrealism

Cirape · Posted: Sun Jul 25, 2004 4:59 pm Post subject:

Goodspeed87 · Posted: Sun Jul 25, 2004 7:46 pm Post subject:

I'm sorta' two sided, he could be a bit more lucrative with the rune, though, he has been right to justify circumstance. It's all a matter of discernment, and as the soul eater consumes him, it's only right to assume it'll take on his identify and force him into seemingly narrow situations.
_________________
Do not despise the snake for having no horns, for who is to say it will not become a dragon?
So may one just man become an army...

	Forum Index -> Character Discussion	All times are GMT - 4 Hours Goto page 1, 2, 3 Next
Page 1 of 3